Clueless Negotiating

I recently saw a press release about a “new eBay-style platform which allows vendors to bypass agents” being launched by non-bank lender inTouch. The release said that the service was designed to deliver transparency and allow vendors to avoid paying agents’ fees.

Sounds fair enough: I don’t mind competition, and I especially respect good competition.

The founder of inTouch, Mr Paul Ryan, was quoted as saying that one of the great frustrations for vendors and buyers was the lack of transparency around the sales process. Their solution was a “vendor assisted” platform they call “Live Offer“.

A later quote attributed to Mr Ryan said: “Live Offer allows the vendor to see offers from real buyers and buyers know what other buyers are offering“.

I mean no disrespect to Mr Ryan or his company inTouch, and I wish him well in his venture. My purpose in mentioning this new offering is to highlight one flaw from a negotiating perspective that, to me, is clueless negotiating, specifically, “…and buyers know what other buyers are offering.”

No negotiation expert will tell you that it is smart negotiating to allow one buyer to hear what another has offered. What one buyer offers is NOBODY’S BUSINESS, except the agent (if one is involved) and the owner of the property under offer.

Yes, buyers at auctions can hear what another buyer has offered, and what do they do? They offer a small amount above the other buyer’s offer. They do not offer the maximum price they are prepared to pay for the property; they offer just $5,000 or $1,000 (and sometimes as low as $100) more than the other buyer.

So just because this happens at auction, it does not mean that allowing one buyer to hear what another has offered is good negotiating.

I hark back to what the experts say, and this is ALL experts, not just a few of them. Experts say that if you want to get a high price for anything, start high and reduce until a buyer is found. They also say that offers should be given in confidence, without other parties being privy to them.

There is transparency and then there is privacy. If I give you an offer, I expect privacy. I expect you to pass it onto the seller, who considers it and then accepts or rejects it, or perhaps asks me for more money – a counter offer.

I do not expect you to blab to another interested buyer and play me off against them. Nor do I believe that displaying my offer to other buyers – as ‘transparent’ as it may be – is anything other than clueless negotiating for any seller who expects to get the HIGHEST PRICE (which is different from a HIGH PRICE) for their property.

It is totally clueless to allow one buyer to know what another will pay. Worse than that, it’s a breach of privacy.

What happens on eBay? Many buyers sit and wait until the dying moments of the auction and then put in a last-second bid that is slightly higher than the current highest displayed offer. Often they win. But does the seller? Does the seller get a high price, or does the seller get the highest price that buyer was prepared to pay?

There can be a massive difference between “high” and “highest”.

Every time I attend an auction and say to the successful bidder, “Congratulations, you must be happy. Tell me, would you have paid more?” On all but ONE occasion, I have received the answer, “Yes“. Most said they would have paid more.

If money is left ‘on the table’, that method of sale has let the seller down.

Clueless negotiating is to allow buyers see each other’s offers.

I’ll take privacy over transparency when I go to sell, thank you very much.

PS If you feel that this article may be of use to potential property sellers, please feel free to distribute it as you see fit.

Recent Articles

Is Excellence Compulsory In Your Agency?


As leaders, we should be the ones setting the standards in our businesses. One standard that should be compulsory is Excellence

The Leader As Coach

Salespeople need far more coaching than typical salespeople receive. In this short leadership session, real estate agency profit consultant, Gary ...

The Enemy of Success

There can be many barriers to success, but one of the greatest challenges for some people is perfectionism. Perfectionism is the enemy of succe...

Courtesy Costs Nothing

Salespeople who treat buyers with disdain would do well to remember that those buyers will become sellers one day. And they will remember those ag...

You Cannot Motivate People

In almost three decades as a real estate agency profit consultant, I have worked with many leaders and interviewed many more. Over this time, I have ...

It's Time To Hire

Shrinking your sales team when your market is tough can shrink your business into oblivion. Join me for this short Leadership Session in which I h...

A Repeat of Last Year

Here we are at the beginning of a new year. But before we get too far into this new year, how were your results last year?Were you happy ...

Think the Best

No doubt you have heard real estate agents blame the market, or clients, for their poor results. "Buyers are liars", or, "Sellers won't see reason...

A Leader's 'Non-Negotiables'

In my 25 years as a real estate agency profit consultant, I have often heard leaders complain that they can't find good people. A second complaint...

Let's Look At The Real Problem

In some markets, real estate agents often say that they have plenty of listings, but need buyers. Real estate agency profit consultant, Gary Pitta...

The More You Learn

Show me an industry where you can earn six-figure incomes without knowing what you are doing. I'll bet that you cannot name one. Yet this is what many...

Is Door Knocking Still Effective?

In a real estate industry poll, over 65 percent of respondents said that door knocking is no longer an effective method for finding new listings. In...

Want to reach your profit potential? Contact us now.

Pittard


Suite 71, Level 4
330 Wattle Street

Ultimo NSW 2007
Australia


Mailing Address
PO Box 2045
Strawberry Hills NSW 2012


: (02) 8217 8500
Fax: (02) 9281 4198
AUS Free call: 1800 663 600
NZ Free call: 0800 448 065
International: +61 2 8217 8500

: info@pittard.com.au

Contact Us